Monday, February 18, 2013
Beginning Rough Draft: Two Teachers
For my paper, I chose Mr. Escalante and Ms. Watson as the two teachers. The focus of my paper is going to be how both teachers played the role of mentors. Mentors are people who understand and listens to people. They support others in where they need the most. I believe one of the characteristics that makes both Mr. Escalante and Ms. Watson is determination. Both teachers were in difficult positions however, both were determined to help their students the best they could. Mr. Escalante showed his determination by pushing his students to take calculus and get college credit. Ms. Watson showed her determination by changing the syllabus and continued to teach art history. They also both advised students when they could. Mr. Escalante helped convince Ana's father to keep her in school. Ms. Watson convinced Joan to apply to Yale Law School. Finally, both teachers taught more than their assigned subjects. They taught lessons that were applicable to real-life like being independent and self-confident.
Monday, February 11, 2013
Define the roles
Mr. Escalante played many roles in the movie. He was a mentor, ally, friend and therapist. He was placed in a very difficult position with rebellious students and a lacking institution. The students did not care for this authoritative position and had no motivation whatsoever. As an ally, Mr. Escalante slowly engaged with his students and learned how to teach to them. As a mentor, he pushed them past their expected limitations. The faculty, parents and even their own selves did not expect themselves to be able to pass the exam for college credit. Along the way, there were doubts and uncertainty within the students, however as a friend, Mr. Escalante helped them through their obstacles to keep them going for the exam. As a therapist, Mr. Escalante noticed that the parents is one obstacle that is hard to navigate through. However, he got involved in his student's personal life and convinced the parents that their children have the ability to further their educational career. On the other side, Mr. Escalante's students were very hard to rude to him in the beginning, however they slowly gained respect for him and motivated themselves to learn. Thanks to Mr. Escalante's contribution and dedication to his student's lives, his students successfully passed the calculus test.
Ms. Watson played similar roles as Mr. Escalante. From what we saw from the movie, she was a mentor, ally and friend. Ms. Watson accepted her role as an art history instructor in a very prestigious school. The community and college was under the control of traditions and strict rules placed by the wealthy families and faculty. Because of this, the college and students were stuck in the mindset of "the right way of doing this." This mindset did not call for creative thinking whatsoever. As a mentor, Ms. Watson decided to break this chain and began teaching her students that art is subjective. There is no right way of art, it is simply abstract. She may not have been seen as an ally in the beginning, however she started opening the eyes of students by making them decide for themselves. As a friend, she motivated one of her students to pursue law and get married. Because of the roles Ms. Watson played, the faculty questioned her teaching style.
Jack MacFarland played similar roles as Ms. Watson and Mr. Escalante. He was a mentor, ally and friend. He was placed in vocational education, where students lacked motivation for learning and furthering their career. As a mentor, he organized a structured curriculum and a number of mixed material. He held reading quizzes ever so often and had his students read interesting books. Not only did he teach about literature but a combination of some history and other subjects to allow his students to absorb the lesson more efficiently. As an ally and friend, Mr. MacFarland helped Rose through his hardest time, which was his father's death. He helped Rose get into college to further his academic career.
Sister MPH played a much different role compared to the other three instructors. She played as a strict disciplinarian and perhaps a mentor as well. Rewards and punishments were a big part of her curriculum. She allowed her "good" students to read aloud to the class and sit in the front. Her "bad" students were placed in the back and did not get opportunities to read out loud. She also accused Lorde of having her parents help with the assignment and reported it to her parents. Luckily, the problem was resolved with Lorde's father insisting that Lorde did her own assignment. In a way, Sister MPH could have played the role as a mentor because the reward-punishment curriculum she had motivated Lorde to do better in her studies. Before, Lorde was not able to distinguish numbers but she had to learn them, if she wished to be classified as a "good" student.
Ms. Watson played similar roles as Mr. Escalante. From what we saw from the movie, she was a mentor, ally and friend. Ms. Watson accepted her role as an art history instructor in a very prestigious school. The community and college was under the control of traditions and strict rules placed by the wealthy families and faculty. Because of this, the college and students were stuck in the mindset of "the right way of doing this." This mindset did not call for creative thinking whatsoever. As a mentor, Ms. Watson decided to break this chain and began teaching her students that art is subjective. There is no right way of art, it is simply abstract. She may not have been seen as an ally in the beginning, however she started opening the eyes of students by making them decide for themselves. As a friend, she motivated one of her students to pursue law and get married. Because of the roles Ms. Watson played, the faculty questioned her teaching style.
Jack MacFarland played similar roles as Ms. Watson and Mr. Escalante. He was a mentor, ally and friend. He was placed in vocational education, where students lacked motivation for learning and furthering their career. As a mentor, he organized a structured curriculum and a number of mixed material. He held reading quizzes ever so often and had his students read interesting books. Not only did he teach about literature but a combination of some history and other subjects to allow his students to absorb the lesson more efficiently. As an ally and friend, Mr. MacFarland helped Rose through his hardest time, which was his father's death. He helped Rose get into college to further his academic career.
Sister MPH played a much different role compared to the other three instructors. She played as a strict disciplinarian and perhaps a mentor as well. Rewards and punishments were a big part of her curriculum. She allowed her "good" students to read aloud to the class and sit in the front. Her "bad" students were placed in the back and did not get opportunities to read out loud. She also accused Lorde of having her parents help with the assignment and reported it to her parents. Luckily, the problem was resolved with Lorde's father insisting that Lorde did her own assignment. In a way, Sister MPH could have played the role as a mentor because the reward-punishment curriculum she had motivated Lorde to do better in her studies. Before, Lorde was not able to distinguish numbers but she had to learn them, if she wished to be classified as a "good" student.
Was Mr. Escalante similar to Mr. MacFarland? How or how not?
Yes, both Mr. Escalante and Mr. MacFarland were similar in a number of ways. Starting with the situations and environment both teachers were in. Both teachers were placed in a room with students that did not care for education and authority. Mr. Escalante was placed in a school that lacked resources and funding. As a result, authority was not re-enforced in the institution. Students became very rebellious and lacked the motivation to progress further in their educational careers. Mr. MacFarland was in a very similar situation as this. He was placed in vocational education, where students lacked motivation and inspiration. However, these situations did not phase or discourage both teachers. Both instructors managed to motivate and gain the respect of their students. Mr. Escalante started having quizzes at the beginning of class and pushing his students to their limits. Mr. MacFarland began assigning many books and held reading quizzes ever so often. Both instructors pushed their students with academics in a structured manner. As a result, students began responding to their teachers and started respecting them. Both instructors started not only engaging in their student's academic life but personal life as well. Mr. Escalante helped convince parents that their children have the potential to further their academic careers. Mr. MacFarland helped Rose during his father's death and helped him get into college. Both instructors were placed in different environments with difficult circumstances, however both managed to adapt and tend to their student's needs.
Reactions to Mona Lisa Smile
At first, I was pretty surprised by the beginning when they held a ceremony before the school year started. Right when I saw that part, I figured that Wellesley was going to be a prestigious institution. What surprised me the most were the strict tradition and rules that surrounded the school and community. Everyone was used to the order of how things were. No one wanted to embrace modern culture. There was an expectation on everyone around. Women were expected to get married, have children and take care of their family. A women who is married and was a lawyer seemed out of the question. However, Katherine Watson did not think this to be true. She was an independent woman who believed in modern culture. She taught art history at Wellesley college and was expected to teach the basics. However instead, Katherine taught the students how to think for themselves. Art is one of those abstract subjects that require insight and perspective. One cannot think art is art based on technique or skill. Art has different meanings and takes different forms to different people. One person might find Da Vinci's Mona Lisa to be a work of art, while a mother might find her child's finger painting picture as art. Everyone has their own opinion on art, therefore, there is no right way of art. It is purely subjective. The women in Katherine's class were born and raised from respected and wealthy families. They were taught that there is a right way to everything in life. "There is a right way of thinking... a right way of living... a right way of art" (Mona Lisa Smile). Katherine represents modern culture in this plot. She shows her students that art is subjective. There is no right way of art. For this reason, the school board questions Katherine's teaching style. To me, Katherine is a good teacher because she reaches out and tries to understand her students. She teaches concepts that are important in real life and uses examples outside of textbook text. Most importantly, she shows them that there is more to life than just marriage, children and people's expectations. Every person is capable of making their own decisions. And I believe Katherine Watson is the perfect candidate to guide her students to modern culture.
Sunday, February 10, 2013
How are the two schools different? Similar?
The two schools are very different from each other. Starting with the lack of funding and resources in Garfield High School. Mr. Escalante was first hired to teach computer science, however because of the lack of funding, computers were not provided to the school. For this reason, Mr. Escalante began his journey as a math teacher. The second difference is the lack of authority present in this school. The faculty does not enforce any security detail or proper punishment on the students. As a result, the students in the school became rebellious and have no respect for authority whatsoever. In one scene, the students rigged the bell timing, resulting in the bell ringing earlier than the usual time. In another scene, two boys walked in late in class. The way the boys walked in class and their tone when they talked to the teacher was disrespectful. Lastly, the level of expectation from Garfield High School is quite low. Because of the school's reputation and current situation, the students have low expectations even for themselves. When Mr. Escalante introduced the idea of teaching calculus, the faculty did not agree because they believe it would shatter the only self-confidence they have. On the other side of the spectrum, Wellesley College is a very prestigious school with plenty of resources. Katherine Watson accepted a position as an art history professor. The women at Wellesley College are smart and have high expectations. They were born and raised in wealthy, respected and elegant families. The Wellesley College and community is surrounded by traditions and strict rules.The women are expected to get married and start families. A women that chooses to do otherwise is looked down upon. With all of the traditions and rules that surround Wellesley College, modern culture is not embraced. Any change is deemed unacceptable and the faculty will do everything they can to make things go back to the way it was. For example, a nurse at Wellesley handed out contraceptives to the students. One of the students reported this incident in the school paper. As a result, the nurse was reviewed by the board and was fired.
Although these two schools are very different from each other, they also have something in common. Both schools have people like Mr. Escalante and Katherine Watson to help the students through different obstacles. At first, in both cases, students showed resistance to the new teachers. Mr. Escalante's first day was a mix of students rigging the bell timing and student's disrespectful attitude. Katherine Watson's first day was a combination of student's arrogance and intimidation. However, both teachers adapted to the classroom atmosphere and managed to engage with the students. Both teachers taught them things, outside of a textbook. To help their students understand how concepts work in the real world, they brought them outside of school walls and showed them the world. Eventually, both sets of students began to understand their lessons and teachers. In both cases, the faculty have doubts about their teaching style. In Mr. Escalante's case, they questioned the student's capability for learning calculus. In Katherine Watson's case, they questioned her teaching method of allowing her students to think for themselves. These are two very different schools with different sets of rules, authority and environment. However, with the two good teachers trying to make a difference, these schools have more in common than one would think.
Although these two schools are very different from each other, they also have something in common. Both schools have people like Mr. Escalante and Katherine Watson to help the students through different obstacles. At first, in both cases, students showed resistance to the new teachers. Mr. Escalante's first day was a mix of students rigging the bell timing and student's disrespectful attitude. Katherine Watson's first day was a combination of student's arrogance and intimidation. However, both teachers adapted to the classroom atmosphere and managed to engage with the students. Both teachers taught them things, outside of a textbook. To help their students understand how concepts work in the real world, they brought them outside of school walls and showed them the world. Eventually, both sets of students began to understand their lessons and teachers. In both cases, the faculty have doubts about their teaching style. In Mr. Escalante's case, they questioned the student's capability for learning calculus. In Katherine Watson's case, they questioned her teaching method of allowing her students to think for themselves. These are two very different schools with different sets of rules, authority and environment. However, with the two good teachers trying to make a difference, these schools have more in common than one would think.
Mona Lisa Smile
The school seemed very orderly, strict and conservative. The new art history teacher, Katherine Watson, was nervous upon entering the classroom on her first day. "Be careful in there, the girls can sense fear" a professor mentioned, passing by. On her first day, the all her students intimidated her by memorizing the text. They verbally dictated the descriptions of each slide presented to them. Afterwards, they intentionally left to independent study. Katherine Watson did not let this phase her. She came up with another set of slides the next day and stunned the students. The students were filled with puzzled and confused looks. This amused Katherine Watson because this enabled her to fulfill her role as a teacher. She continued to challenge her students and began to understand them individually. The community and school is surrounded by rules and tradition. There is a "right way of thinking" or a "right way of art." Art, however, is one of those abstract subjects that require creativity and perspective. The concept of "there is no right way of art" is what Katherine Watson is trying to teach. This concept started causing some suspicion among the faculty. The people believe that there is a right and wrong answer to every question. They avoid change. They want things to stay in order. The issue with contraceptives being distributed by the nurse resulted in the nurse getting fired. Women are expected to get married and have kids. However, Katherine Watson opened another gate. She views the alternative lives women can choose to take like having a job and waiting to get married. One student chose to accuse Ms. Watson of challenging the "role the girls were born to do" (Mona Lisa Smile). Throughout the movie, the women are expected to be happy with marriage. However, there are a number of affairs and lies going around. The Wellesley College decided to welcome Ms. Watson back for another year, however she declined the offer. She did not want to change and conform. She came to Wellesley to make a difference and she did. She showed the girls the world through a different perspective.
Saturday, February 9, 2013
In Class Writing: What do you think makes a good teacher?
Teaching is a mutual
relationship between a teacher and a student. If one side does not understand
the other, the relationship becomes disrupted. A good teacher is someone
who can makes an effort to form the mutualistic relationship. This entails understanding
the situation or circumstance and engaging in the lessons and
students. A great example of this relationship is the movie Stand and
Deliver. In the beginning, the newly appointed math teacher, Mr. Escalante, had
problems with handling his students because the students were rebellious and
had no respect for authority. For instance, in the beginning of the movie,
students rigged the bell timing which caused the bell to ring sooner than the
anticipated time. Another example was in the scene when the two boys arrived
late in class. They both had no intention in learning and were disrespectful by
talking back in an aggressive one. Mr. Escalante adapted into this extreme
environment, where the students ran free, the faculty had no control and the
school lacked supply and funding, and understood his students. He taught basic
math and used real world applications to his students. He had interactive and
fun lessons which got his students' attention. This growing,
mutualistic relationship slowly transformed into a family.
He believed in his students and pushed them year after year. He got
involved with their families to help further their career towards college
education. Although the faculty had doubts about the limitations of these
students' abilities, the students and Mr. Escalante's mutual relationship
overcame the issues that unfolded during the movie.
According to Brown,
"Great teachers have strong relationships with students' families and
engage in meaningful ways with the larger community" (Brown - pg
2). In the movie, Stand and Deliver, Mr. Escalante got involved with
Ana's family. Ana's dream were to get a college education and
continue on to medical school. However, her father wished for her to work in
the restaurant along with her mother and siblings. Mr. Escalante
tried his best to convince Ana's father otherwise. Although Ana's
father found Mr. Escalante disrespectful, he let his daughter
continue going to school. Mr. Escalante shows his engagement with the community
by teaching night classes for free. To show the extent of his dedication, Mr.
Escalante had a heart attack from his stressful schedule. Another one of
Brown's criteria mentions that good teachers need to "force their way into
the public discourse to advocate for their students and their profession"
(Brown - pg 2). Mr. Escalante demonstrates this in the scene where he mentions
that he will teach calculus to his students. The school faculty had doubts
about the student's ability to pass the exam for college credit. However, Mr.
Escalante believed in his students. To prepare his students, he had longer
class periods and held summer school sessions.
"Creativity is as
important as literacy. And we should treat them with the same status,"
Robinson mentions in his lecture. He believes that in every country, the
priority in education is the same. Math, science and English always took priority and is being strongly reinforced in our current educational system. Subjects like art, music and drama should just be as important as math and science. However, because of our current educational system, children grow out of their creative aspect. Creativity is needed for the future. It is creativity that allows original ideas to formulate. Young children are not afraid of being wrong. It is this exact attitude that is needed for create original ideas. One must not be afraid of being wrong. However, in our society, mistakes and being wrong are the worse things you can do in life. Robinson believes that a good teacher allows a child to be creative. A good teacher would encourage creativity and teach that being wrong is not always a bad thing.
Dr. Robinson believes that a good teacher encourages student's creativity. Dr. Escalante emphasized math on many different levels. However, it is not the kind of creativity Robinson was referring to. Another one of Robinson's criteria that makes a good teacher is to teach students not to be afraid of being wrong. In a couple of scenes in the movie, Mr. Escalante was not happy whenever students made mistakes during their lesson. However, the situation was complex in this case. The students and Mr. Escalante were both pressured by the calculus exam and the faculty's expectations. They only had a short amount of time to study for the exam and they power-studied through the book. The students spent long days and nights of studying and studying, afraid to betray the expectations of the faculty and Mr. Escalante. In this case, it is hard to rate Mr. Escalante based on Robinson's criteria for what makes a good teacher. The reason being, Mr. Escalante is not an art, music or theatre teacher. He is a math teacher hired to teach computer science. However, there are different aspects in math where creativity is needed. Whether this creativity is the same as the one Robinson was referring to is debatable. In subjects like math, there is only one answer. There may be many different ways one can approach a math equation, however there is only one answer that is correct. During this time, the students and Mr. Escalante were both under pressure. This is a factor that could contribute to student's fear of making mistakes. Therefore, I believe it is truly difficult to rate Mr. Escalante based on Robinson's criteria.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)